Where Do We Go to Belong?

Image from Vecteezy.com

Image from Vecteezy.com

I sit here, in my warm house, with snow accumulating by the inch in Cambridge, crumbling inside about what is happening outside, in my country. Yesterday, I went down a rabbit hole watching reel after reel - scenes from brave souls protesting ICE and federal agent occupation in minus 20 degree temps in Minneapolis to tributes to the lives lost and upended with the unnecessary violence and cruel targeting. I came upon one heartbreaking video of a young Asian-American boy, crying in the backseat of his mother’s car, in a soccer uniform with a medal around his neck. In what should have been a victorious moment, this boy was crying about the taunting and bullying he faced on the field by the goalie. The goalkeeper told him that he was “an illegal immigrant” even though he was born in America, that Trump was gonna get him and send him back “to where he used to live.” The young boy, exasperated and crying says, “I was born in America. I haven’t lived anywhere else.” And I guess that’s the crux of the issue. Where do those of us, born in this country or becoming citizens through naturalization, truly belong?

I think back to when my dad came to the United States. It was 1975. His mother, my grandmother, had sold her jewelry so that my father could buy his plane ticket to make the trip across the ocean. America held so much promise and being an ever optimist, my father embraced this journey with such zeal and excitement. My father’s story is similar to many other immigrants looking to make America their new home. My father eventually sponsored his two brothers and their families. We were “all in” as a family on the American promise. For the most part, those hard days of sacrifice of leaving their families and their homes and facing covert racism in their work places and within their adopted towns and cities proved to be worth it. This past week, my brother officially received the department head’s notice that he received tenure at Johns Hopkins University. Earlier this month, I started my first stint as a General Counsel for a nationwide nonprofit. Most of us children of immigrants are success stories in our own right, accomplishing the proverbial American Dream.

And still, I look at my parents and wonder what they must be thinking now, and how much things have changed in our country. I wonder if they would still make the decision to emigrate here, knowing all that they know now. I wonder what it must feel like to still feel like you don’t belong after decades of following the laws and rules, paying both state and federal taxes and into the social security system, and contributing to their communities. During the first Trump presidency, my mother - who has been in this country since she was 17 - was told to go back to her country during her daily walk in our neighborhood that she has lived in for 45 years. My mother wears her hair in one plait and a bindi on her forehead. She is noticeably straddling two cultures and for that, after being in this country for 63 years at the time, the underlying racism she had endured here finally became overt. It finally became acceptable to say the unacceptable to immigrants like my mother and apparently, to the little boy in the reel.

Lately, I’ve been thinking about what being American really means. About whether we, as children of immigrants and immigrants, will ever truly feel like we belong. Will my children feel like they belong? Will my grandchildren ever be accepted? Perhaps that feeling I had as a child of trying to fit in was always going to be futile in a system that was never going to accept us. Perhaps the most painful question of all for my parents and any immigrant is whether achieving the American Dream is worth it if it comes without true acceptance. And I think to that little boy, who could have been any one of our children, crying in the backseat of his mother’s car, asking the most basic of questions: what does it take to actually belong? Because today, as I sit in my warm house, I honestly do not know. And I grieve for my parents and all immigrants about that loss of a promise of something as great, as wonderful, as what was the American Dream.

My greatest teachers

I am an enthusiastic podcast listener. I love listening to a range of podcasts but usually focus more on politics and current events, life lessons and how best to live one’s life, and women, culture and careers. Every now and then, I hear nuggets of wisdom that I try to incorporate into my life. But as I was listening to a podcast recently, I heard supposed “lessons” that were pretty basic. I researched the experts and found out that they were just normal people like you and me spewing supposed “life lessons” to undiscerning listeners. While it was certainly a wakeup call to be be more discriminate about the content you are consuming, there was also a silver lining. That as of late for me, my greatest teachers are not ones I am listening to over a podcast or watching on Instagram reels but the very humans that I helped bring into the world; my greatest teachers are my children.

I know, it’s cliché in some respects (and I will write a post some day about the downsides of our self-help/self-improvement culture), but the point is that teachings are expert and age agnostic. And what we may need to learn in this moment may be right in front of our eyes and come from the most unlikely sources.

When Kabir first started out skiing years ago, he wasn’t getting it. Something wasn’t clicking for him. His fear of falling and not connecting with the instructor were all factors preventing him from learning the basics. Thus, he wasn’t progressing like his sister and our good family friends, all of whom were younger than him. While the other kids had advanced to their first green, Kabir was relegated to the “bump,” one notch below the bunny slope. As he stood there, watching his little sister and friends go up the chairlift, he felt humiliated. It didn’t make it easier that his little sister teased him for being on the bump. But instead of giving up and giving in to the humiliation, he doubled down. With unwavering commitment, drive and motivation to conquer skiing, Kabir not only made it up the chairlift onto a green by the end of the day, but he beat his sister down the mountain.

Kabir is the hardest worker I know. His work ethic is unparalleled to anything I have seen a young person doing in a while. When he sets his mind to something, he will work ad nauseum to make it happen. It’s relentless the way he will drill down on the task from studying for an AP exam to learning the ins and outs of his favorite sports. He gets obsessed with what his goals are and there is no distracting him from it. I joke with my friends that he has no time for girlfriends or anything really because he is so “locked in.” In theory, we know that hard work, dedication and commitment yields results. For example, we know that the #1 reason that diets fail is because people lack discipline and consistency. Our minds know all of this. But its one thing to know something mentally and another to actually DO what you know. Kabir is teaching me daily how it is done. In real time and in real life, he leads by example and is one of my greatest teachers.

My other great teacher is my daughter, Navya. Earlier this week, Navya and I went to see Dua Lipa at TD Garden with a few of her good friends. In the lead up to the concert, the moms discussed having the girls wear sequins skirts. As any obliging mother, I ordered a few on Amazon (and paid for two-day shipping since I cancelled my Prime membership- a story for another time). From the moment my daughter came home from school, she was looking out the front door in anticipation of the package’s arrival. Thankfully, it arrived in time and my daughter bounded up to her room to try them on. The skirts were all quite short. My daughter paired one of the gold sequins skirts with a black top, put black shorts underneath, all the while looking quite unsettled and unsure. I looked on from the door of her room with a bit of skepticism, however, I stayed silent. I’ve learned the hard way that it’s best to keep quiet over issues like dress and hair with a 12-year old girl. I left the house to grab food so we could head out to the concert.

When I came home, Navya announced boldly and unequivocally that she wasn’t going to wear the gold sequins skirt. She said she just didn’t feel comfortable. Mind blown! I don’t know many 12-year old girls, including myself when I was that age, who could put their feelings and comfort ahead of those of their peers. Navya knew her friends would all be matching in their sparkly sequins but she still chose to wear what felt best for her and her body. Not only was this a proud mom moment, it was such a lesson in being confident in who you are and owning that feeling. She showed me that she does not need external validation to feel good about herself and that what is most important is to listen to your gut and go with what makes you feel the best. It has taken me four decades to learn that lesson and to be honest, it is still hard for me. As we left for the concert, Navya not only looked beautiful in her still too-short blue skirt, but so confident and sure of herself. You go girl!

My children are not perfect nor do I want them to be. They make plenty of mistakes and are still learning the ropes of how to live their lives. But they are my greatest teachers as well as my greatest gifts. Now, only their mother can say that :)

Who are your greatest teachers?

Some Thoughts

I am not OK. I have been struggling for weeks now. This feeling is different and one that I haven’t felt for years. The last time I felt this way was when I was in conflict-torn Bukavu, visiting Panzi Hospital in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. I haven’t talked about my time there in detail. Mostly, it’s because it hurts, still to this day, and I feel the complete hopelessness that I feel right now. I had just visited the pediatric ward for sexual violence survivors. Yes, you read that correctly. I had met two and three-year old girls who had been brutally raped, their tiny organs ripped apart by the depravity of grown men. There was so much in that visit, but what struck me the most was that despite the evil, hatred and cruelty, these girls found it within themselves to smile. To still believe that their lives would get better. And so amidst this backdrop, knowing all that these criminals had taken from them, they chose hope.

These last few weeks feel similarly because of these feelings of despair and hopelessness. When I was in the DRC, it sometimes felt like I was in an alternate reality. Is what I am seeing and experiencing really happening? Because if it was, how are we all not feeling like this? How can this be happening and people are carrying on their daily lives? How can we know that this is happening, watch these awful videos of children being maimed, orphaned, and killed, and turn away? How can we allow this suffering, born primarily by women and children, to continue? And all not feel the pain to our very core?

In all of these awful conflicts, I am always bewildered that we can’t see the humanity in others. Why can’t we understand that a Palestinian mother or father grieving the loss of their baby or child is the same as the Jewish mother or father grieving the loss of theirs? Human suffering is universal. It knows no bounds. And yet we are told that one narrative is more compelling, worthy of action and the other is not. I will choose to not get political here because this isn’t about that anymore. We left politics at the station weeks ago. This is about our collective humanity. This is about the universal truths that bind us together. If we can’t see this now, after so much evidence and data, I fear for our future and for our society. I fear that “Never Again” was a hollow promise.

We do what we can for our children. So I will continue to show up for mine. But these last few weeks have been almost unbearable. To bear witness to the abject pain and suffering is the absolute least I can do, in my cushy, warm, home and my full, hydrated body. If my feelings, prayers and energy that I put out in the world can help in some minute way, I will take it because to do otherwise, would be soul-crushing. I will bear witness so that when my children are older, I can at least say that I felt. I cried. And I suffered a tiny fraction. I can look myself in the mirror today and tomorrow knowing that while my heart is broken, I still have one that beats to the drum of humanity. I can muster the courage to smile to that, with the hope that this fake smile will one day again be real. Just like the little girls in the Congo.

Representation Matters

Liam Daniel / © Netflix

Truth be told, I can’t stop watching Bridgerton Season 2. Eyerolll. I know, I get it. Much has been written about how Bridgerton inaccurately depicts Indian culture, completely ignores the harm and devastation caused by colonialism, and the mundane plot line. Added to these criticisms, the distinction between North and South India is confusing- the Sharma sisters, Edwina and Kate, call their father “appa” (a Tamil word for father) while Edwina calls her older sister “didi” (a Hindi word for older sister). They speak Hindustani, a mixture of Hindi and Urdu often spoken in the North, but they are South Indian in appearance and on the show. (Side note: It’s baffling to me that while these shows spend thousands of dollars on elegant wardrobes and stage sets, that they can’t do simple desk research to get these aspects of another’s culture correct.)

All of this aside, I rejoiced at seeing somebody who looked like me on screen. It was one of the first times that I’ve seen a dark-skinned, South Indian actress play the lead role and be the object of affection of a White, leading man. This all sounds warped especially this day in age where you see South Asian representation everywhere and being coveted by a White person no longer carries the same symbolism nor should it. However, I can’t recall a time where a dark-skinned, South Indian actress is the object of desire by a mainstream man not out of some weird, exotic fetish but simply for being her. Kate Sharma (played by Simone Ashley) is displayed in all her beauty and radiance with complex depth and emotion. She is desired not just for her looks, but for her personality, wit and grace.

Devouring episode after episode of Bridgerton, I wonder what this depiction would have done for me had it been available in my childhood. Growing up in the 80s and 90s, I was surrounded by the rom coms of Sixteen Candles, Dirty Dancing, Princess Bride, Pretty in Pink, Sleepless in Seattle, My Best Friend’s Wedding and Never Been Kissed. The list goes on but the connecting theme is that of a White leading lady being pursued or wanted by a White leading man. I used to dream about being suddenly noticed and swept off my feet by Michael Schoeffling (THE Jake Ryan of Samantha’s dreams). But then I would look in the mirror and realize that there was no way it was possible for an Indian American girl like me.

During this time I also started watching Indian movies, mostly Hindi movies, as those were the ones coming our way. I remember visiting India after 1942: A Love Story came out. The songs, the dancing, the love story all sucked me in - I dreamt about being Manisha Koirala dancing in the rain and singing Rim Jhim Rim Jhim and of catching Jackie Shroff’s fancy. What is fascinating is that despite being Nepalese, Koirala depicted what was seen as beautiful for that time: fitting a certain mold of beauty of being fair-skinned. All the South Indian actresses that made it in Bollywood up until this point were fair-skinned (and gorgeous)- Aishwarya Rai, Sridevi and Rekha to name a few. Again, the message was clear from Hollywood to Bollywood: beauty was not me.

All these castings left girls like me out of the equation- beauty didn’t include a dark-skinned South-Indian girl with an American accent and hairy arms and legs. And that limited what I could see for my future. It affected my confidence profoundly, who I could see myself with and what I desired. We hear people say this all the time, that representation matters. I can honestly say that it does. It matters for those little girls and boys who are yearning to see people like themselves on screens, in positions of power, and as role models in society. It matters to be able to see what is possible and to not be limited by others. It matters who we see as beautiful and worthy of affection. Representation matters.

I’m grateful that my daughter can now see that beauty includes girls like her and that the only thing limiting her dreams is her own imagination. As a young girl, I would have given anything to see Kate and Edwina Sharma on screen as leading ladies catching the fancy of a handsome Viscount. Maybe I too would have believed in my beauty and more importantly, myself, as well.

Letting Priya's Spirit Free

December 2019, Hyderabad, India - Priya, left, helping her little cousin Navya, right, celebrate her birthday.

It’s been a really long time since I’ve written and I’m not sure why. So much has changed for me in the past three months, but then again, so much hasn’t. It’s ironic that the last post I wrote about was that of the death of my dear mother-in-law almost 4 years gone. Because now as I write this, I am in India with my husband, helping my sister-in-law and her family with the loss of their daughter, Priya. My heart breaks all over again, this time, for a life that was lost too soon, for a family that will be profoundly altered for the rest of their respective lives over the loss of a daughter who held court, stole people’s hearts and minds and defied all odds to become a college-educated, employed, strong young woman despite her disabilities.

Even though we have dealt with the pandemic and cataclysmic changes in work, school and health and loss over these past two years as a society, still nothing prepares you for death. I think that’s what has caught me most off guard these past eleven days. That even though we’ve been surrounded by such loss of life and uncertainty and have had to become more flexible and nimble in our daily lives, that the permanence of death still can hit you so hard. Intellectually you know it’s always a possibility with anybody you hold dear, but in life, despite it all, your heart settles on hope and positivity. Even though there is so much bad going on in the world right now, the promise of life, of hope, of love carries you to the next moment. Until that next moment is one of death.

For the past two days, I’ve been sitting with my sister-in-law. Most times we don’t speak. I sit there in her pain. I cannot ever know the true depths of her despair and utter devastation. But I sit there, knowing that I have no ability to take any of it away from her. I listen to her tell stories of her Priya, of her suffering, her last days and minutes, and also of her triumphs, of her character and personality and of what she will miss. I worry that she will feel the despair of loneliness and we will be thousands of miles away, caught up in our daily lives to not be with her. To not sit with her. To not allow her to share her pain.

You can tell so much about a culture by how they care for those grieving. In my culture, there are 10-13 days of mourning. In those days, those who have lost their loved ones are not left alone and surrounded by family and friends. Each day there are ceremonies performed by a priest. The 10th day after death, which we observed yesterday for Priya, is perhaps the hardest day for those who believe in spirits and an afterlife. It is the day where we who are left behind must sever our ties with the spirit of the departed. We must let her go, let her spirt free, so the spirit can fulfill its destiny. With our clothes on, we purify ourselves with a cold water shower. We then perform a simple ceremony performed by the priest who instructs us how to cut our ties to Priya. We thank her for blessing our lives with her presence, for giving us so much of herself. And then in a moment, our bonds are cut forever. We then take another cold water shower, marking the end of our relationship with the deceased. For my sister-in-law and brother-in-law, the pain of that severance was almost too much to bear. The finality so cruel. As a mother and father, can you ever really detach from your child?

As we went back to my sister-in-law’s place yesterday, I am convinced that despite it all, nothing prepares you for death. But the heart, in all its defiance to one’s mind, soldiers on with hope, love and possibility. I pray that this hope, love and possibility will carry my sister-in-law, brother-in-law and nephew through this next difficult period knowing that the ache of losing Priya will never erase completely and only dull in time.

RIP my dear Priya. You have changed our lives for the better and we will miss you so very much. Goodbye thali.