Two Truths and a Lie
These are the facts:
Christa Pike survived a botched lethal injection attempt in Tennessee involving two doses of pentobarbital on September 30, 2026.
A 16-year-old opened fire at Silver Rail Elementary School in Bend, Oregon, shooting and killing three children, ages 5, 8 and 11, and a 25-year-old teacher on October 15, 2026.
On October 7, 2026, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth announced the livestreaming of the military execution by firing squad of Nidal Hasan, a former U.S. Army psychiatrist who killed 13 people in a shooting at Fort Hood, Texas, in 2009. Trump reversed the decision on October 15, saying the execution would proceed but would not be livestreamed.
Each one of these facts alone is enough to warrant full papers of analysis and research. But how do we contend with these facts when taken together? On the daily, and with increasing frequency, we as a society are having to grapple with difficult news stories that are supposed to yield emotions and responses that are seemingly contradictory. I’ll admit that the frequency of this type of news, coupled with the constantly changing news cycle, leaves me numb and paralyzed more often than not. What is shocking to me is that only one of these events prompted swift political action and a reversal of policy. Sadly, it wasn’t the botched execution or the school shooting.
The execution of 50-year-old Christa Pike was meant to bring a sense of justice for the victim. Pike was found guilty of the gruesome murder of Colleen Slemmer, committed when Pike was 18. But when you read the details of Pike’s botched execution attempt, harrowing doesn’t seem to capture her experience. Pike was brought to a local hospital with both arms swollen, burned and blistered, in critical condition and needing life-saving medical support. The execution team faced severe difficulty accessing veins, using multiple needles (at one point, there were up to seven in her arms). According to accounts in court filings, the lethal chemical, pentobarbital, leaked into the surrounding tissue. Pike was to be the first woman executed in Tennessee in 200 years. This was the second failed execution attempt in five months in Tennessee. Tennessee has been grappling for years with untested and inconsistent processes of lethal injection. Even for those asking for justice for Colleen Slemmer, this display of brazen violence towards Pike violates something fundamental about the sanctity of human life.
We are then brought to another school shooting a few weeks later in Bend, Oregon, by a 16-year-old. Again, the victims of this horrific crime were children, ages 5, 8 and 11, as well as a 25-year-old teacher. This was only a blip across my phone—an alert that sprung up and disappeared within seconds—news that has become so commonplace that it barely registers as news. We move on so quickly as a nation, to the next news alert, and God forbid, the next school shooting. But to those in Bend, these scars of devastation and loss endure, with no clear signs of abatement in meaningful and effective gun law reform. On a recent podcast promoting his latest book, The American Way of Killing: The Invention of an Epidemic, Malcolm Gladwell discusses visiting elementary schools on the South Side of Chicago and meeting an emergency room doctor who is training fourth graders as first responders to gunshot wounds. Now sit with that for a minute. Two things: that you probably didn’t bat an eyelash at another school shooting and that fourth graders (9–10-year-olds) are being taught how to respond to gunshot wounds. You would be lying if you said these facts didn’t leave you a little queasy.
But sandwiched between the Pike execution and the Bend shooting was the Trump administration’s announcement that Nidal Hasan would be executed by firing squad in public and that this execution would be livestreamed. This announcement garnered the most outright public outrage, prompting immediate political action. In this announcement, Trump brought into sharp relief two forms of violence that are particularly pronounced in America in their scale and magnitude: the normalization of state-sponsored violence through executions and civilian violence through widespread gun ownership and gun violence. The United States is an outlier among wealthy, democratic nations that still actively practice capital punishment. The vast majority of the world has turned away from the death penalty, either by law or practice. With respect to guns, again, the United States is a unique global outlier in gun ownership and firearm-related mortality compared to other wealthy, democratic nations. We have the highest rate of civilian gun ownership in the world, with roughly 121 firearms per 100 residents (representing 393 million civilian-owned guns!).
What has made the combination of our acceptance of capital punishment and widespread civilian gun ownership so troubling when it comes to Nidal Hasan? The livestreaming of an execution by firing squad. The public nature of the firing squad execution. In this announcement, we met America’s redline. In a Washington Post/ABC News/Ipsos poll conducted October 9–13, 53% of Americans supported executing Hasan by firing squad. But 80% opposed livestreaming the execution. While our track record with executions and gun violence is undeniable, what makes them easier to accept for the American public is that they remain largely hidden, unspoken and unacknowledged. Lethal injections are the primary method of execution in the United States and were widely adopted to appear more “humane” and “medicalized” than the traditional methods of electrocution, lethal gas, hanging or firing squad. It’s easier to grapple with the government taking away a life when the delivery is a needle to the arm. And we know our history of guns. While the Second Amendment purports to provide cover for civilian gun ownership, Gladwell and other scholars convincingly argue that these common interpretations of the Second Amendment are rooted in historical misunderstandings. This is not to suggest that the violence resulting from civilian gun ownership is simply an unavoidable consequence of this “fundamental right.”
What makes me uncomfortable when I put all of this together is that the normalization of, and seeming indifference to, state-sponsored executions and civilian gun violence can persist and thrive without meaningful political action as long as they remain hidden from the world. But the moment that we livestream and broadcast what Americans have come to accept as our reality, that garners public condemnation for its cruelty and barbarism. Almost immediately, Trump faced widespread bipartisan backlash from lawmakers, military officials and the populace over the broadcasting of the public execution. For how could we be in the company of countries such as Afghanistan, North Korea and Iran? As long as we do not broadcast what goes on behind closed doors, we can keep believing the biggest lie of all: that violence done quietly is somehow more civilized than violence performed in the open.
Source: Washington Post/ABC News/Ipsos, October 15, 2026. Survey of 2,545 U.S. adults. Poll conducted October 9–13, 2026.